_edited.png)
Both the Atlantic Highlands & Highlands boroughs of Monmouth County are picturesque coastal towns in New Jersey, they’re not only known for their stunning views of the New York City skyline and rich maritime history but also for their burgeoning pizza scene. This article takes you on a culinary journey through each town’s finest pizza establishments, where every slice tells a story of tradition, innovation, and community.
Amici Pizzeria: A Hidden Local Gem
In the charming town of Atlantic Highlands, Amici Pizzeria stands out as a beloved destination for pizza enthusiasts. This hidden gem isn't just a place to grab a slice; it's a testament to family tradition and culinary passion. The driving force behind Amici Pizzeria is a wonderful family, Anthony and Melanie Fabbri who are parents to four young children and pour every ounce of their soul into the business.
Anthony Fabbri is a second generation pizza maker who was inspired by his father Silvio, a skilled pizzaiolo who founded the popular Umberto’s Pizzeria in Fair Haven NJ. From a young age, Anthony was immersed in the art of crafting the perfect pizza. Learning from his father, he follows his family values of hard work, dedication, and an unwavering commitment to quality. These lessons became the foundation upon which Anthony built Amici Pizzeria.
Today, Amici thrives on high-quality ingredients and traditional methods, evident in every hand-tossed dough and carefully selected topping.
The menu boasts a mix of classics like Margherita pizza and creative options like a Bianca pie with an everything bagel crust, along with salads, subs, pastas and appetizers. The fried gnocchi and the bee's knees knots are local favorites! The warm, welcoming atmosphere, friendly staff and the aroma of freshly baked pizza make dining at Amici special. You can also rent out a private dining space for parties or come see one of their pop up events like open mic night!
The Fabbri family also gives back to the community, participating in local events and fundraisers, supporting schools, charities and organizations. They also have partnerships with growing local small businesses to market and offer products in their shop. This commitment reflects their belief in the importance of community.
Amici Pizzeria is a testament to Anthony and Melanie’s passion and perseverance, offering a dining experience that celebrates family and tradition. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, a trip to Amici promises a heartwarming and delicious meal. Amici means “friends” in Italian, and that's exactly the atmosphere Anthony and Melanie cultivated with Amici Pizzeria, when you enter their establishment you’re immediately treated like family!
Strada Pizza Bar: A Neighborhood Hangout
Strada, nestled in the heart of First Avenue, offers a unique dining experience centered around its wood-burning oven. This 70-seat quaint, trendy neighborhood pizza bar is always bursting with energy from the moment you walk in. Chef Ken Mansfield's restaurant features a variety of inventive appetizers, such as whipped sheep’s milk ricotta with lemon zest, and a mantecato made from smoked trout with crudités, adding a touch of gourmet flair to traditional comfort foods.
Pizzas at Strada are a wood fired masterpiece with options like the soppressata pie topped with sicilian olives, burrata, and oregano or the mais pie finished with local corn, fior di latte, jalapeno and pepperoni, combining fresh ingredients and bold flavors. The dough, crisped to perfection in the wood-fired oven, serves as the perfect canvas for these creative toppings.
Beyond the mouth watering food, Strada's bar scene has a fun community vibe. The bar offers a curated selection of cocktails, wines, and craft beers that pair well with the menu items, enhancing the overall dining experience. Cocktails are created with precision, and the wine list features both local and international selections, ensuring there’s something for every palate.
Strada's ambiance is both festive and welcoming, making it an ideal spot for a casual night out or a special celebration. The lively atmosphere is complemented by attentive service, ensuring guests feel both comfortable and well-cared for during their visit.
This is a must-try restaurant for a unique dining experience where you can eat, drink and relax. Let Strada’s wonderful staff allow you to indulge in “il dolce far niente” - Italian for “the sweetness of doing nothing” except eating some amazing pizza!
Julio’s Pizza Co: A local favorite slice spot!
Another First Avenue local favorite, Julio's Pizza Co. is more than just a pizza joint—it's a community hub with a heartwarming story. Founded by Erin and Brendan, the pizzeria is inspired by their rescue dog, Julio, embodying a spirit of love and community. The cozy eatery quickly became a local favorite, renowned for its friendly atmosphere and delectable offerings.
One standout creation that has put Julio's on the map is their famous Joe Joe's Pickle Pizza. This unique and mouthwatering delight features a crispy crust topped with a creamy garlic sauce, mozzarella cheese, and a generous layer of dill pickles. The unexpected combination of tangy pickles and rich cheese has captivated the taste buds of many, making it a must-try item for anyone visiting the area.
But Julio's is not just about innovative pizzas. The menu also boasts a variety of fresh and flavorful options, including classic and specialty pizzas, hearty subs, crisp salads, and an array of snacks. Whether you're in the mood for a quick slice, a satisfying sub, or a full family meal, Julio's has something to offer everyone.
In addition to its delicious food, Julio's Pizza Co. is deeply committed to giving back to the community. They offer catering services for events and celebrations, ensuring that their tasty creations can be enjoyed on any occasion. Moreover, their PUPSXPIZZA merchandise line is a testament to their dedication to animal welfare, with all proceeds benefiting the Monmouth County SPCA (MCSPCA).
The welcoming environment at Julio's, coupled with its mouthwatering menu and community-driven initiatives, makes it a standout spot in Atlantic Highlands. Whether you're a local or just passing through, a visit to Julio's Pizza Co. promises not only a fantastic meal but also a connection to a place that truly cares about its community.
Franny's Pizzeria & Restaurant: Where the Jersey Shore Begins
Let’s not forget the neighboring town of Highlands NJ. Tucked away on the charming Bay Avenue, Franny’s Pizzeria & Restaurant stands as a testament to family tradition and culinary passion. Owner Mya Anitai delivers a fresh take on a neighborhood BYOB hangout, with indoor seating as well as an outdoor dog friendly patio-garden.
Franny’s Pizzeria & Restaurant isn’t just a place to grab a slice—it’s a cornerstone of the Highlands community, rooted in a deep commitment to quality and family values. Mya, the driving force behind the establishment, took a 40 year classic pizzeria and has made it a modernized must-visit pizza spot at the very tip of the Jersey shore.
The pizzeria’s success is attributed to its unwavering focus on using the freshest ingredients and maintaining a warm, welcoming atmosphere that resonates with locals and visitors alike. Mya emphasizes the importance of keeping the family’s culinary traditions alive, which has been central to Franny’s identity since its beginning.
One of Franny’s must-have pies are the oil-pressed, square, Grandma style pizzas. The Tipsy Nonna is a community favorite with thin, crispy crust, topped with delicious creamy vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella and a touch of basil - this pie will keep you coming back for another slice of Franny’s Granny.
Through community engagement and a genuine love for serving delicious food, Franny’s Pizzeria has carved out a special place in the hearts of its patrons. Mya has also created specialty events, like dog friendly pizza get togethers, collaborations with local chefs for tasting menus, wine pairings, sip-n-swaps for artwork and more. There's always something going on at this local hot spot. For my NYC Commuters, you’re in for a treat, Franny’s pizza is available on select Seastreak Ferries to and from NYC.
As Franny’s continues to thrive, it remains a shining example of how a family’s commitment to excellence and community can create a lasting legacy in the competitive world of pizza.
Atlantic Highlands and the Highlands may be small towns, but the pizza scene is anything but! Each of these pizzerias brings something special to the table, showcasing both of these town’s diverse culinary talent and passion for great food. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, be sure to stop by these top pizza spots and enjoy a slice (or two) of Highlands’ finest!
Comentarios